Scotland's Assisted Dying Bill Defeated by 12 Votes; Sponsor Rules Out Reintroduction
MSPs rejected the controversial "Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults" bill in a close Holyrood vote of 69 to 57, with only twelve more votes needed than required. Liam McArthur, who sponsored and successfully introduced legislation that would have allowed terminally ill adults facing six months or less life expectancy legal assistance at end-of-life care options after the defeat on Monday night has ruled out reintroducing it in a future parliament despite his party's continued support for assisted dying nationally Labour MSPs largely voted against him.
Key Points
-
1The 'Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults Bill' was defeated in Holyrood by a margin of six votes (69-57) after an intense debate.
-
2Sponsor Liam McArthur has ruled out reintroducing the legislation, despite his party's support at Westminster and frustration among Labour MSPs who voted against it due to lack of backing from their own colleagues. The bill would have allowed terminally ill adults with a six-month prognosis access to assisted dying if passed.
Developments
MSPs defeated Liam McArthur's assisted dying Bill on Tuesday night with a final vote count that was reversed from its initial stage one approval. The legislation failed by 69 to 57 after cross-party members switched sides due to concerns regarding legal risks, protection for health workers and vulnerable groups, as well as the potential coercion of terminally ill adults into ending their lives
Liberal Democrat MSP Liam McArthur announced he will not reintroduce Scotland's failed Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults Bill after it was defeated by 69 votes to 57. Following five years of legislative efforts, including accepting over 150 amendments prior to the vote which resulted in emotional reactions from supporters and colleagues within Holyrood chamber
Scotland's assisted dying measure was defeated in Holyrood by 12 votes after only three of Labour MSPs supported it despite a majority backing similar legislation at Westminster. Liam McArthur expressed devastation over the result and announced he would not reintroduce the bill following May's election, citing concerns that many MPs recognize current bans cause excessive suffering but voted against re-legalizing assisted dying due to political pressure ahead of local elections.
The Scottish Parliament voted against Liam McArthur Assisted Dying Bill by six votes to allow terminally ill Scots with a prognosis under one year, following three previous failed attempts in 2015 and earlier years. Although the bill secured more support than any prior effort on this issue was had it passed would have granted competent patients aged over twenty-five choice of end their own lives within five months if they were suffering from an incurable condition or terminal illness